CALL US: 206.533.3854
CALL US  206.533.3854
AEON Law logo full color transparent
By Colibri1968 at English Wikipedia - Transferred from en.wikipedia to Commons., Public Domain,

Patent Troll Targets the Open Source Community

GNOME beats patent troll,
Fights rather than settle cheap,
Wins for open source

We have written before about “patent trolls,” who are more politely called “patent assertion entities” (PAEs) or “non-practicing entities” (NPEs).

A troll/PAE/NPE is an entity that owns patents but doesn’t actually make items covered by the patents. Instead, it licenses the patents to others and sues to enforce its rights.

PAEs can be problematic because they sometimes sue to enforce weak patents that wouldn’t stand up to a court challenge, counting on defendants to settle relatively cheaply rather than potentially spend millions on patent litigation.

For example, in 2014, we blogged about MPHJ Technology Investments, a company that the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) called a “poster child” for patent abuse.

In 2012, MPHJ sent letters to more than 16,000 small US businesses, demanding $1,000 to $1,200 per employee for them to license its scanner technology.

MPHJ claimed that anyone merely using a scanner violated its patent rights.

Due to abuses by companies like MPHJ, several states passed anti-patent-troll laws, calling bad-faith assertion of patent rights an unfair business practice.

The profile of patent trolls has receded since this 2013 New York Times article. A leading cause of this decline was the 2014 Supreme Court case of Alice Corp. vs. CLS Bank International, which made it harder for plaintiffs to prevail in cases involving software patents.

However, patent trolls haven’t gone away.

In 2019, Rothschild Patent Imaging, a PAE, brought suit against the GNOME Foundation, which (according to its website) is helping to create a free software computing platform for the general public that is designed to be “elegant, efficient, and easy to use.”

The GNOME Project is an example of “open source” software. Open-source software has source code that anyone can inspect, modify, and enhance.

Rothschild claimed that GNOME’s “Shotwell” desktop image organizer and editor infringed its patent for “Wireless Imaging Distribution System and Method.”

While many defendants in suits by PAEs settle, GNOME decided to fight. Working with a major patent litigation firm that provided its services pro bono, GNOME was able to discover prior art that called into question the patent’s validity.
In May, GNOME obtained a free license to all relevant Rothschild patents – scoring a win for its open-source community.

Just like the haiku above, we like to keep our posts short and sweet. Hopefully, you found this bite-sized information helpful. If you would like more information, please do not hesitate to contact us here.

Related Articles

Just Because It’s on the Internet Doesn’t Mean It’s “Publicly Accessible”

The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB or Board) has denied institution of a petition for inter partes review (IPR) because the petitioner failed to ...
Read More

Trademark Denied for “ChatGPT”

The US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has denied OpenAI’s applications to trademark “ChatGPT” and “GPT.” The Final Office Action states, “Registration is refused because the applied-for mark ...
Read More

Federal Circuit: “Improving User Experience” Isn’t Patentable

The Federal Circuit has affirmed a lower court decision that patent claims for methods and systems for improving how search results are displayed to users ...
Read More

Stay Informed

Sign up to receive Patent Poetry—a monthly roundup of key IP issues in our signature haiku format. Four articles (only 68 syllables); zero hassle.



Artificial Intelligence

Blockchain & Cryptocurrency

Computer Technology & Software

Consumer Electronics

Electrical Devices



Mechanical Devices

Consumer & Retail Products

Hardware & Tools

Toys & Games



Chemical Compounds

Digital Health

Healthcare Products



Books & Publications

Brand Creation

Luxury Products

Photography & Video

Product Design