CALL US: 206.533.3854
CALL US  206.533.3854
Full color aeon logo
By Kalmia - Self-published work by Kalmia, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=1140105

Physical Check-Processing Doesn’t Pass § 101 Test

Federal Circuit
Finds patent claims are abstract
Though checks are for real

The Federal Circuit has ruled that patent claims can still be “abstract” even though the claimed invention involves the processing of physical checks.

Solutran, Inc. v. Elavon, Inc. involves a 2012 patent for a system and method for processing paper checks.

As the patent explains,

in the past, the payee would transport the check to his or her own bank to be read and processed, then the payee’s bank would transport the check to the payor’s bank, where it also would be read and processed. 

As the court noted,

The patent describes its invention as a system and method of electronically processing checks in which (1) “data from the checks is captured at the point of purchase,” (2) “this data is used to promptly process a deposit to the merchant’s account,” (3) the paper checks are moved elsewhere “for scanning and image capture,” and (4) “the image of the check is matched up to the data file.” 

Solutran, the patent owner, sued US Bank alleging infringement of the patent.

US Bank countered that the asserted patent claims were invalid under 35 U.S.C. § 101 for failing to recite patent-eligible subject matter in that they were directed to the “abstract idea of delaying and outsourcing the scanning of paper checks.”

The Federal Circuit agreed that the claims of the patent were directed to an abstract idea – but to a somewhat different abstract idea than the one asserted by US Bank:

We conclude that the claims are directed to the abstract idea of crediting a merchant’s account as early as possible while electronically processing a check.

The court also concluded,

Contrary to Solutran’s arguments, the physicality of the paper checks being processed and transported is not by itself enough to exempt the claims from being directed to an abstract idea. 

Related Articles

Federal Circuit Allows “Trump Too Small” Trademark

Federal Circuit:
First Amendment allows the
“Trump Too Small” trademark

Read More

When is trademark generic?

Generic trademarks:
Won’t be granted to start with,
And can be cancelled

Read More

AEON Law Founder Named Crypto “Trailblazer” by the National Law Journal

Adam Philipp, the founder of AEON Law, has been recognized among the leading practitioners of blockchain, cryptocurrency, and fintech law by the National Law Journal.

Read More

Stay Informed

Sign up to receive Patent Poetry—a monthly roundup of key IP issues in our signature haiku format. Four articles (only 68 syllables); zero hassle.

SERVICES

PROTECT

International IP Protection

DEAL

DEFEND

Opinions