The Seventh Circuit has affirmed a summary judgement in favor of gestalt therapists who published a book including an article that was accused of infringing the copyright of unpublished manuscripts.
The case is Center for Gestalt Development, Inc. v. Bowman.
As the court explained,
In many areas of the law, a greater power incorporates a lesser one. So it might seem intuitive that someone with the right to publish a collection of certain writings could publish any one of those writings individually. But the Copyright Act of 1976 works differently, providing that the copyright owner of an aggregate work has no automatic right to publish any of its components standing alone.
The case involves a dispute over the rights to publish an article titled “Psychopathology of Awareness” by Dr. Frederick Perls. Dr. Perls never published the article on a stand-alone basis, and his copyright in it passed to his wife Laura Perls upon his death in 1970.
After Laura died in 1991, her estate entered into an agreement with The Center for Gestalt Development that conveyed exclusive rights to publish a collection of Dr. Perls’s unpublished manuscripts, including the article at issue.
Defendants-Appellees Charles Bowman and Jean-Marie Robine reproduced the article in 2019 as part of a book bearing the same name, with the permission of the Perls’s heirs.
By the time the Center gained the copyright to the article in 2021, the heirs had already granted Bowman and Robine permission to use the article in their book.
The court explained that
Sometimes an author (or a third party, with the author’s permission) assembles several copyrighted writings into a single, unified compendium. The Copyright Act designates the package, such as “a periodical issue, anthology, or encyclopedia,” as a “collective work.” … The Act then labels the collective work as a “compilation.”
The key point, noted the court,
is that, pursuant to § 103(a) of the Copyright Act, a compilation is equally eligible for copyright protection as is any of its components, so long as the compilation itself satisfies the requirements of authorship, originality, and fixation.
However, the scope of a compilation’s copyright is limited:
copyright in a compilation … extends only to the material contributed by the author of such work, as distinguished from the preexisting material employed in the work, and does not imply any exclusive right in the preexisting material.
The copyright in a compilation “is independent of, and does not affect … any copyright protection in the preexisting material.”
Stated differently, said the court,
the owner of a so-called compilation copyright does not necessarily own any rights to the underlying writings within the compilation, because the copyright in a compilation protects “only the elements that owe their origin to the compiler.”
To clarify further, the court suggested:
To visualize these distinct ownership interests, consider how copyright law applies to a magazine that publishes a volume composed of articles written by freelance authors. The freelancers hold a copyright in the article they wrote, and the magazine holds a copyright in the volume it assembled.
Also, unless the author of an individual article has separately conveyed their copyright in the article, the author retains the exclusive right to reproduce their article.
In this case, the Center for Gestalt Development learned of Bowman’s and Robine’s book before it went to press and litigation ensued.
A federal court concluded that the 1991 agreement granted the Center rights only in the collection of Dr. Perls’s unpublished manuscripts, not any of the underlying articles—including the “Psychopathology of Awareness.”
The Circuit Court concluded that
As of 1991, then, the Center had no more of a right to publish the article, except as part of the collection along with the other unpublished manuscripts, than a magazine has a right to reproduce any of its freelancers’ articles in isolation.
Just like the haiku above, we like to keep our posts short and sweet. Hopefully, you found this bite-sized information helpful. If you would like more information, please do not hesitate to contact us here: https://aeonlaw.com/contact-us/.